When it comes to iconic comfort food, few dishes rival the universal appeal of pizza. Whether you're craving a wood-fired Neapolitan slice, a classic deep-dish, or a thin-crust loaded with toppings, the pizza scene in Hinsdale, IL, delivers a delicious variety that satisfies every palate. This affluent suburb, known for its tree-lined streets, luxury homes, and tight-knit community, also happens to be a low-key haven for pizza lovers.
Whether you're a long-time local or a newcomer considering homes for sale in Hinsdale, IL, this guide will take you through the very best pizza places in Hinsdale, IL, including fan favorites, family-owned treasures, and those offering the most reliable pizza delivery in Hinsdale, IL.
Why Hinsdale, IL is a Hidden Pizza Gem
Hinsdale may be best known for its historic architecture and top-rated schools, but it's also home to some of the finest pizza joints west of Chicago. Many restaurants here have been passed down through generations, keeping family recipes alive, while others bring modern twists to classic styles. And with a variety of dine-in, takeout, and pizza delivery Hinsdale, IL, options, residents are never far from a satisfying slice.
1. Giuliano’s Pizza — A Local Institution
A beloved family-owned pizzeria since 1991, Giuliano’s Pizza is a staple in the Hinsdale dining scene. Known for their crispy thin crust and hearty deep-dish pies, this spot blends old-school charm with dependable quality. Don’t miss the sausage and giardiniera combo—an ode to Chicago's pizza traditions. They also offer generous catering options and reliable pizza delivery in Hinsdale, IL, making them a go-to for both casual dinners and celebrations.
Local Favorite: Giuliano’s Special (sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, and onions)
2. Altamura Pizza — Artisan with a Modern Flair
If you're craving something a little more upscale, Altamura Pizza offers a gourmet experience with a focus on high-quality, organic ingredients. Baked in a wood-fired oven imported from Italy, their Neapolitan pizzas feature hand-stretched dough and flavorful sauces. With a chic atmosphere and curated wine list, Altamura is perfect for date nights or weekend indulgence.
Must-Try: Truffle Mushroom Pizza or their Burrata Margherita
3. Baldinelli of Hinsdale — Family-Friendly Favorite
A cozy and welcoming spot downtown, Baldinelli of Hinsdale offers something for everyone. Their pan pizza is thick, cheesy, and incredibly filling, while the thin crust still holds its own in terms of flavor. With TVs for sports fans and plenty of seating for families, it’s one of the more versatile pizza places in Hinsdale, IL.
Hot Pick: BBQ Chicken Pizza and their homemade garlic bread
4. Brasi’s Pizzeria — A True Hidden Gem
Small in space but big on flavor, Brasi’s Pizzeria is a lesser-known treasure among pizza Hinsdale, IL, aficionados. The menu features customizable options with fresh ingredients and house-made sauces. Their thin-crust pizza has the perfect crunch-to-cheese ratio, and they offer a loyalty program for frequent visitors.
Popular Combo: Pepperoni, banana peppers, and black olives
5. Fox’s Pizza of Hinsdale — Old-School Vibes
Fox’s in Hinsdale is where locals go for a classic pub-style pizza experience. Known for its crispy thin crust and generous toppings, it also serves as a lively community hangout. It’s one of the few places that nails the balance between a casual bar atmosphere and excellent food. Plus, Fox’s offers dependable pizza delivery in Hinsdale, IL, making it an easy weeknight dinner solution.
Don’t Miss: The Deluxe Pizza and the Italian Beef Sandwich
Honorable Mentions: More Pizza to Love
While these five are the standout stars, other local pizzerias are also worth checking out:
-
Lucca’s Pizzeria: Known for their flavorful sauce and cheese blends
-
Vincitori: Offers Italian dining with delicious flatbread-style pizzas
-
Home Run Inn (nearby in Darien): Famous Chicago pizza with frozen options available in-store
Pizza Delivery in Hinsdale, IL: Fast, Hot, and Reliable
In today’s fast-paced world, the convenience of pizza delivery in Hinsdale, IL, cannot be overlooked. Whether you’re entertaining guests or just too busy to cook, these restaurants have you covered with reliable delivery services:
-
Giuliano’s Pizza – Known for quick turnaround and consistent quality
-
Fox’s of Hinsdale – Offers both phone and online ordering
-
Baldinelli – Provides family-style delivery perfect for group gatherings
Pro tip: Ordering through the restaurant’s own website or app often gets you fresher deals and better pricing than third-party apps.
Thinking About Moving to Hinsdale, IL?
The incredible food scene is just one reason people are drawn to Hinsdale. If you're exploring homes for sale in Hinsdale, IL, you're not just buying a property—you're investing in a lifestyle filled with small-town charm, excellent schools, and top-tier amenities (like amazing pizza!).
And when it comes to real estate, few know the area better than Megan McCleary, a top-producing broker with McCleary Group. With years of experience and deep local connections, Megan helps clients navigate the Hinsdale real estate market with ease and confidence.
Final Slice: Hinsdale’s Pizza Scene is as Elevated as Its Lifestyle
From gourmet wood-fired pies to family-friendly pan pizzas, the pizza in Hinsdale, IL, reflects the community's commitment to quality, tradition, and flavor. Whether you’re a longtime resident or new to the area, this western suburb offers a pizza experience that rivals even the big city.
So next time you’re in the mood for a cheesy indulgence, skip the chains and explore the rich variety of pizza places in Hinsdale, IL—your taste buds will thank you.
Ready to Make Hinsdale Your Home?
If you're dreaming of life in a community with great schools, beautiful homes, and a food scene that includes the best pizza around, contact Megan McCleary of McCleary Group today. With her insider knowledge and dedication to client success, she’ll help you find the perfect place to call home in Hinsdale, IL.
